Skip to the content
Peabody TeachFor teachers and grown-ups

Aunt Winifred's Weather Knee

8th grade fiction passage about a tall tale about a forecasting knee: 275 words, six questions, an answer key and vocabulary.

8th grade fiction a tall tale about a forecasting knee 275 words

Aunt Winifred's Weather Knee

Folks in the dry valley of Cobble Flats liked to say that Aunt Winifred Tuck owned the most accurate knee in the whole country. Whenever rain was on its way, her left knee gave a creak so loud that neighbors could hear it across three fences. Before a thunderstorm, it performed a little drumroll. Before snow, it let out a long, shivering whistle, and the children would run for their mittens. The weather office in the city had cost a fortune and employed forty scientists, yet it was wrong about half the time, so the entire valley trusted the knee instead.

Trouble arrived one summer when Winifred bumped that knee against a pie cart. From then on it gave only confusing signals. On Monday it creaked, drummed and whistled all at once, which seemed to promise rain, thunder and snow before supper. The mayor canceled the town picnic in a panic. The sky stayed perfectly blue, the pies went stale, and people began to mutter that the famous knee had finally retired without telling anyone.

Winifred, who was a practical woman, visited the doctor, and the doctor gave a simple answer. The knee was not broken. It was exhausted from years of carrying heavy crates of apples and pies up the hill. The cure was rest, a cushion, and a helper to do the lifting. Winifred hired a strong boy named Teddy, and within a week the knee settled down. It still grumbled in a low, offended mumble whenever a cloud drifted past, but the forecasts were as sharp as ever, and the picnic was rescheduled for a day the knee swore would be sunny.

Questions

  1. Which of Winifred's knees predicted the weather? in the text

  2. What did the knee do before a thunderstorm? in the text

  3. What caused the knee to give confusing signals? in the text

  4. What did the doctor say was wrong with the knee? in the text

  5. Why did the valley trust the knee more than the weather office? think about it

  6. How can you tell that the story is a tall tale? think about it

Words to know

accurate
correct and free of mistakes
forecasts
predictions about what the weather will be
practical
sensible and good at solving real problems
exhausted
completely worn out and tired
drumroll
a quick, rattling beat of a drum
Share

One passage, three levels

The same topic and facts written three ways, so a mixed class can read and talk about one text. Each group’s sheet shows only a shape; the key says which is which.

● Easier · 223 words · Flesch-Kincaid grade 2.9

In the dry valley of Cobble Flats, people said Aunt Winifred Tuck had the best knee in the country. When rain was coming, her left knee gave a creak. You could hear it across three fences! Before a thunderstorm, it did a drumroll. Before snow, it whistled, and the children ran for their mittens. The weather office in the city had forty scientists. It was wrong half the time. So the whole valley trusted the knee.

Then one summer Winifred bumped her knee on a pie cart. After that, it gave strange signals. On Monday it creaked, drummed and whistled all at once. That seemed to mean rain, thunder and snow before supper. The mayor canceled the town picnic. But the sky stayed blue, and the pies went stale. People said the famous knee had retired.

Winifred was a sensible woman. She went to the doctor. The doctor said the knee was not broken. It was tired. For years it had carried heavy crates of apples and pies up the hill. It needed rest, a cushion and a helper. Winifred hired a strong boy named Teddy. In a week, the knee was calm again. It still grumbled when a cloud drifted by. But its forecasts were good once more, and the picnic was held on a day the knee said would be sunny.

▲ This passage · 275 words · Flesch-Kincaid grade 7.3

Folks in the dry valley of Cobble Flats liked to say that Aunt Winifred Tuck owned the most accurate knee in the whole country. Whenever rain was on its way, her left knee gave a creak so loud that neighbors could hear it across three fences. Before a thunderstorm, it performed a little drumroll. Before snow, it let out a long, shivering whistle, and the children would run for their mittens. The weather office in the city had cost a fortune and employed forty scientists, yet it was wrong about half the time, so the entire valley trusted the knee instead.

Trouble arrived one summer when Winifred bumped that knee against a pie cart. From then on it gave only confusing signals. On Monday it creaked, drummed and whistled all at once, which seemed to promise rain, thunder and snow before supper. The mayor canceled the town picnic in a panic. The sky stayed perfectly blue, the pies went stale, and people began to mutter that the famous knee had finally retired without telling anyone.

Winifred, who was a practical woman, visited the doctor, and the doctor gave a simple answer. The knee was not broken. It was exhausted from years of carrying heavy crates of apples and pies up the hill. The cure was rest, a cushion, and a helper to do the lifting. Winifred hired a strong boy named Teddy, and within a week the knee settled down. It still grumbled in a low, offended mumble whenever a cloud drifted past, but the forecasts were as sharp as ever, and the picnic was rescheduled for a day the knee swore would be sunny.

■ Harder · 285 words · Flesch-Kincaid grade 9

Residents of the arid valley of Cobble Flats liked to boast that Aunt Winifred Tuck possessed the most dependable knee in the entire country. Whenever rain was approaching, her left knee emitted a creak so resounding that neighbors could hear it across three separate fences. Before a thunderstorm, it performed a modest drumroll. Before snow, it released a long, shivering whistle, and the children would scramble for their mittens. The weather office in the city had cost a small fortune and employed forty scientists, yet it was mistaken about half the time, so the whole valley placed its faith in the knee instead.

Disaster struck one summer when Winifred collided with a pie cart and bruised that very knee. From then on it produced only baffling signals. On Monday it creaked, drummed and whistled simultaneously, which appeared to promise rain, thunder and snow before supper. The mayor, in a panic, canceled the annual town picnic. The sky remained perfectly blue, the pies went stale, and residents began to mutter that the celebrated knee had retired without informing anyone.

Winifred, who was a thoroughly practical woman, consulted the doctor, and the doctor offered a straightforward diagnosis. The knee was not broken at all. It was simply exhausted from years of hauling heavy crates of apples and pies up the hill. The prescription was rest, a soft cushion, and a helper to do the lifting. Winifred hired a sturdy boy named Teddy, and within a week the knee had settled down. It still grumbled in a low, offended mumble whenever a cloud drifted past, but its forecasts were as sharp as ever, and the picnic was rescheduled for a day that the knee swore would be sunny.

Download as one PDF

How to use it

  1. Press Read it big (or B) to put the text on the projector, or Full screen (F) to fill the whole screen.
  2. Ask the questions one at a time and use Show answer when the class has decided. A shows or hides every answer.
  3. Print student copy for the class, or Print with answers for yourself.

Ideas for class

  • Before reading, put accurate, forecasts, practical, exhausted and drumroll on the board with their meanings from the Words to know section and have students predict what the story will be about.
  • Read it aloud once while students follow along, then have them reread it alone or with a partner. At a calm 100 words a minute it takes about 3 minutes to read aloud.
  • Use the Read it big button (or B) to put the text on the projector, and Show answer on one question at a time so the class commits to an answer first.
  • Question 5 asks the reader to infer. Ask students to point to the words in the passage that led them to their answer.
  • Ask students to retell the story in three sentences: how it began, what the problem was, and how it ended.
  • Print the student copy for independent work and keep the answer-key copy for yourself.

Related

Questions

What reading level is "Aunt Winifred's Weather Knee"?

It was written for 8th grade. It has 275 words and works out to a Flesch-Kincaid grade level of about 7.3. That is a formula's estimate from sentence length and syllables, and it is not a Lexile or a guided reading level, so check it against your students.

What do the questions ask?

There are six. 4 ask for something the text says directly and 2 ask the reader to work something out from clues. Each has an answer in the key, and the answers are written as a teacher would accept them, not as the only possible wording.

How long does it take to read?

About 3 minutes read aloud at 100 words a minute. For a one-minute fluency check, paste it into the fluency timer and use the word count.

Can I print it?

Yes. Print student copy gives the passage, the questions with lines to write on, and the word meanings. Print with answers gives the same page with the answers filled in. Both are made in your browser.

Is this passage from a published book?

No. It was written for Peabody Teach, so there is no book to buy and no login to read it.

Nothing you do here is sent to us. No sign-in, no ads.