Reading: no design is perfect
Name ______________ Date ____________
How can a bridge made of paper hold a heavy load? No design is perfect, so engineers weigh trade-offs. A trade-off is giving up some of one good thing to gain another. A thicker beam is stronger, but it is heavier and costs more. A drone with strong parts can carry more, but strong parts weigh more, so its battery runs down faster. Engineers list criteria, what a design must do, and constraints, the limits on materials, cost and time. Then they compare designs against both.
Engineers use models to test ideas before they build the real thing. A model can be a drawing, a computer program or a small copy called a scale model. Models are cheaper and safer than full-size tests. But models have limits. A small model may not act like a large structure, because weight grows faster than strength as a structure gets bigger. So engineers check a model against real tests.
A decision matrix helps compare designs. List the criteria, give each design a score for each one, and add the scores. Each score is a judgment, so the best design depends on what matters most. Tests give data to back up the scores. When a test fails, engineers find the failure point, change one part and test again. Repeating this cycle of testing and improving is called iteration.
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| trade-off | Give up one good thing to gain another |
| criteria | What a design must do |
| constraint | A limit on materials, cost or time |
| model | A drawing, program or copy used to test |
| scale model | A small copy of a larger object |
| decision matrix | A table that scores designs |
| iteration | Repeating a cycle of test and improve |
Activity: strength per sheet
Materials: scissors, tape, six sheets of paper, two stacks of books set 20 cm apart, about 80 pennies. Steps: 1. Build Design A from one sheet, Design B from two sheets and Design C from three sheets. Each must span the gap. 2. Add pennies one at a time in the middle until the bridge bends to the table. 3. Record the pennies held. 4. Divide pennies by sheets to find the pennies per sheet. 5. Improve your best design and test it again.
| Step | What to do | Safety |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Cut and tape the paper | Use scissors only; an adult is nearby |
| 2-3 | Add pennies one at a time | Keep the load low to the table |
| 4 | Divide to find pennies per sheet | Do not lean over the bridge |
| End | Collect pennies and paper | Wash your hands when you finish |
| Design | Sheets | Pennies held | Pennies per sheet |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | 1 | ||
| B | 2 | ||
| C | 3 |
Which design was strongest overall? Which used paper best? What did you give up?
Practice 1: recall
Picture word: a see-saw. Adding weight to one side takes it away from the other. A trade-off is like a see-saw.
Draw a see-saw with strength on one side and weight on the other.
Choose the best answer.
- A trade-off isa) giving up some of one thing to gain anotherb) a test that always worksc) a kind of bridge Answer: giving up some of one thing to gain another
- Criteria area) limits on costb) what a design must doc) the data from a test Answer: what a design must do
- A constraint isa) a goal for strengthb) a scale modelc) a limit on materials, cost or time Answer: a limit on materials, cost or time
- A scale model isa) a small copy of a larger objectb) a full-size buildc) a list of scores Answer: a small copy of a larger object
- A decision matrixa) draws a bridgeb) scores designs against the criteriac) measures force Answer: scores designs against the criteria
- Iteration meansa) testing only onceb) building the final designc) repeating a cycle of test and improve Answer: repeating a cycle of test and improve
Practice 2: apply
Choose the best answer.
- A drone arm is made thicker. It is stronger but heavier. This shows aa) trade-off between strength and weightb) constraint on timec) failed test Answer: trade-off between strength and weight
- Bridge A held 24 pennies with 2 sheets. How many pennies per sheet?a) 24b) 12c) 48 Answer: 12
- Bridge A held 24 pennies with 2 sheets. Bridge B held 30 with 3 sheets. Which used paper better?a) Bridge B, with 10 per sheetb) They used paper equallyc) Bridge A, with 12 per sheet Answer: Bridge A, with 12 per sheet
- Design X scores 3, 4 and 2. Design Y scores 4, 3 and 3. Which is best by the matrix?a) Design Y with 10b) Design X with 9c) They tie Answer: Design Y with 10
- A model bridge holds a big load. What should the team do next?a) Skip any further testingb) Check it with a real test, since models have limitsc) Make the model smaller Answer: Check it with a real test, since models have limits
- A test shows a bridge fails at a joint. What is the next step?a) Stop the projectb) Test a different bridgec) Change the joint and test again Answer: Change the joint and test again
Practice 3: explain and compare
Choose the best answer.
- Why is no design perfect?a) Improving one criterion often costs anotherb) Engineers are carelessc) Tests never work Answer: Improving one criterion often costs another
- Why use a model before a full-size build?a) Models are always exactb) It is cheaper and safer to testc) Models cannot fail Answer: It is cheaper and safer to test
- Why might a small model not act like a big structure?a) Small models have no weightb) Big structures have no limitsc) Weight grows faster than strength as size grows Answer: Weight grows faster than strength as size grows
- Why can two teams pick different best designs?a) They may give different importance to the criteriab) One team ignores datac) Matrices always tie Answer: They may give different importance to the criteria
- Why does iteration improve a design?a) It makes the first design perfectb) Each test shows a weakness to fixc) It removes the need for criteria Answer: Each test shows a weakness to fix
- How are criteria and constraints different?a) They mean the sameb) Constraints are goals; criteria are limitsc) Criteria are what a design must do; constraints are limits Answer: Criteria are what a design must do; constraints are limits
Check
True or false, then choose.
- A perfect design never needs a trade-off.TrueFalse Answer: false
- A scale model is a smaller copy used for testing.TrueFalse Answer: true
- Iteration means testing a design only once.TrueFalse Answer: false
- A decision matrix scores designs against criteria.TrueFalse Answer: true
- Which is a constraint?a) The bridge should be strongb) Only two sheets of paper are allowedc) The bridge should be useful Answer: Only two sheets of paper are allowed
- A model can have limits that a real test shows.TrueFalse Answer: true
- Name one trade-off in designing a drone. Answer: Strength versus weight (also: strong but heavy, weight and battery)