Reading: bridges, drones and big builds
Name ______________ Date ____________
How can a bridge made of paper hold a heavy load? Engineers solve problems with a design process. First they state the problem. They list criteria, the things a good solution must do, and constraints, the limits on materials, cost and time. Then they brainstorm ideas, build a prototype, test it and improve it. A prototype is a first model used for testing.
Shape matters. A flat sheet of paper bends under almost no weight. Fold it into an accordion pattern or roll it into a tube and it holds much more, because the folds spread the weight out. The load is the weight that a structure carries. Triangles are strong because they do not change shape easily under a load. Many bridges use a truss, a frame built from triangles.
Testing shows the failure points, the places where a design bends or breaks first. A failure is not a waste. It tells the engineer what to fix. To compare designs fairly, change one thing at a time and keep the rest the same. Repeat each test several times. Drone designers use the same steps. They need parts that are strong and light, because a heavy drone needs more battery power.
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| criteria | What a good solution must do |
| constraint | A limit on materials, cost or time |
| prototype | A first model used for testing |
| load | The weight a structure carries |
| truss | A frame built from triangles |
| failure point | Where a design bends or breaks first |
Activity: the paper bridge
Materials: three sheets of paper, two stacks of books set 20 cm apart, about 50 pennies, a pencil, a ruler. Steps: 1. Lay one flat sheet across the gap. 2. Add pennies one at a time in the middle. Stop when the paper sags to the table. 3. Record the pennies. 4. Fold a second sheet into an accordion, and test it the same way. 5. Roll a third sheet into a tube and test it. 6. Do three trials of each design.
| Step | What to do | Safety |
|---|---|---|
| 1-3 | Test the flat sheet | Keep the load low to the table |
| 4-5 | Test the folded and rolled sheets | An adult is nearby |
| 6 | Repeat each test three times | Do not lean over the bridge |
| End | Collect the pennies | Wash your hands when you finish |
| Design | Trial 1 | Trial 2 | Trial 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Flat sheet | |||
| Accordion fold | |||
| Rolled tube |
Which design held the most pennies? Where did each one fail first?
Practice 1: recall
Picture word: a truss looks like a row of triangles joined in a line, like a zigzag.
Draw a truss: a zigzag of triangles between two posts.
Choose the best answer.
- What is a prototype?a) A first model used for testingb) The final product on salec) A list of materials Answer: A first model used for testing
- Criteria area) limits on time and costb) the things a good solution must doc) the pieces of a truss Answer: the things a good solution must do
- A constraint isa) a test resultb) a shape made of trianglesc) a limit on materials, cost or time Answer: a limit on materials, cost or time
- A load isa) the weight a structure carriesb) the way a bridge looksc) the paper used to build Answer: the weight a structure carries
- A truss isa) a round tubeb) a frame built from trianglesc) a flat sheet Answer: a frame built from triangles
- Which shape keeps its form well under a load?a) A rectangle with loose jointsb) A flat sheetc) A triangle Answer: A triangle
Practice 2: apply
Choose the best answer.
- A flat sheet bends under 2 pennies. The same sheet folded holds 40. Why?a) The folds spread the weight and make it stifferb) Folding adds more paperc) Pennies weigh less on folded paper Answer: The folds spread the weight and make it stiffer
- A team may use only three sheets of paper. This is aa) criterionb) constraintc) prototype Answer: constraint
- The bridge must hold 30 pennies. This is aa) constraintb) failure pointc) criterion Answer: criterion
- In a test, a bridge bends first in the middle. The middle is thea) failure pointb) trussc) load Answer: failure point
- To compare two bridge designs fairly, you shoulda) change the paper and the designb) use the same paper and gap and change only the designc) test each one once Answer: use the same paper and gap and change only the design
- A drone team picks a strong, light material over a strong, heavy one. Why?a) Light materials are always cheaperb) Heavy materials cannot be strongc) A heavy drone needs more battery power Answer: A heavy drone needs more battery power
Practice 3: explain and compare
Choose the best answer.
- Why is a failed test useful?a) It shows which part to fixb) It proves the project is overc) It makes the next test easier Answer: It shows which part to fix
- Why repeat each test three times?a) To use up more penniesb) Results vary a little, so repeats show the patternc) To make the bridge stronger Answer: Results vary a little, so repeats show the pattern
- Why does a rolled tube hold more than a flat sheet?a) It has more paperb) Tubes are lighter than flat sheetsc) Its shape spreads the weight instead of letting it bend Answer: Its shape spreads the weight instead of letting it bend
- Why do bridges use triangles in a truss?a) Triangles resist changing shape under a loadb) Triangles look nicec) Triangles use less paper than lines Answer: Triangles resist changing shape under a load
- Bridge A held 12 pennies and bridge B held 30. Only the folds were different. What is the best conclusion?a) Bridge A is strongerb) The folded design held more in this testc) Folding made no difference Answer: The folded design held more in this test
- Why build a prototype before the final design?a) Because prototypes must be finished productsb) To skip testingc) To find problems early and fix them cheaply Answer: To find problems early and fix them cheaply
Check
True or false, then choose.
- The design process includes testing and improving.TrueFalse Answer: true
- A failed test means the work was wasted.TrueFalse Answer: false
- A load is the weight a structure carries.TrueFalse Answer: true
- A fair test changes several things at once.TrueFalse Answer: false
- Which is a constraint?a) The bridge should hold 20 penniesb) Only three sheets of paper may be usedc) The bridge should look tidy Answer: Only three sheets of paper may be used
- A truss is a frame built from triangles.TrueFalse Answer: true
- After a test shows a failure point, what should the engineer do? Answer: Improve the design (also: fix it, redesign it)