Two sides
Name ______________ Date ____________
Many questions have two sides. A reason FOR gives a good thing about a choice. A reason AGAINST gives a cost or a problem. A fair thinker listens to both sides before they decide.
Warm-up: for or against?
- A class talks about a longer recess. Which is a reason FOR it?a) Children get more time to run and playb) Lessons would have less timec) The bell is loud Answer: Children get more time to run and play
- Same class. Which is a reason AGAINST a longer recess?a) Children like to runb) Lessons would have less timec) Recess is outside Answer: Lessons would have less time
- Looking at both sides means you only listen to the side you like.TrueFalse Answer: false
- When a question is about taste, like a favorite pet, two people can both be right.TrueFalse Answer: true
- A school can plant a garden or build a swing set on an empty lot. Which is a reason for the garden?a) Swings are made of metalb) The lot is emptyc) Students can grow vegetables Answer: Students can grow vegetables
Weigh the choices
Stretch: costs and benefits
- A class can keep a hamster. Which is a reason AGAINST it?a) It likes to run on a wheelb) It needs daily care, even on weekendsc) It has four legs Answer: It needs daily care, even on weekends
- Which question has two reasonable sides?a) Is a triangle a shape with three sides?b) Should the class have game time on Fridays?c) Is 10 more than 5? Answer: Should the class have game time on Fridays?
- Side A says, 'Homework helps you practice.' Side B says, 'Free time helps you rest.' What is true about both?a) Both give a reasonb) Only A gives a reasonc) Neither gives a reason Answer: Both give a reason
- A school wants to start earlier so it can end earlier. Which is a benefit?a) Students get more time after schoolb) Some students must wake up earlierc) The bus must come earlier Answer: Students get more time after school
- Same plan. Which is a cost?a) Students get more time after schoolb) Students go home earlierc) Some students must wake up earlier Answer: Some students must wake up earlier
- A fair summary of a disagreement gives each side's best reason.TrueFalse Answer: true
Fair thinking
Reach: go deeper
- Side A: 'A longer lunch lets us eat slowly.' Side B: 'A shorter lunch gives more class time.' What do both sides want?a) To skip lunchb) To use the school day wellc) To end school sooner Answer: To use the school day well
- Someone says, 'Only one side has good reasons.' What is the best next step?a) Agree right awayb) Stop listeningc) Read the other side's best reasons first Answer: Read the other side's best reasons first
- 'Everyone does it' is a weak reason. Why?a) A crowd doing something does not show it is a good ideab) Crowds are always wrongc) Crowds are quiet Answer: A crowd doing something does not show it is a good idea
- A park can add a skate ramp or more benches. Which fact would help most to decide which one more children would use?a) The color of the benchesb) The age of the parkc) A count of children who visit each place Answer: A count of children who visit each place
- A class votes on a game party or a pizza party. 14 vote for the game party and 9 vote for the pizza party. How many more votes did the game party get? Answer: 5
- Hearing both sides means you must always pick the middle.TrueFalse Answer: false
Both sides table
For a grown-up and child together: pick a small choice, like a pet, a game or a new rule at home. Fill in the table. Then ask: which reason is strongest, and why? What would you need to know to be more sure?
| For | Against |
|---|---|