Skip to the content
Peabody Teach

Share

This page

Peabody is free and has no ads. Sharing it is the best way to help.

Critical thinking: both sides

Three tiers of looking at both sides of a question, from warm-up to reach, with a key, for grades 4 to 6.

Grades 4 to 6 · 25 minutes · worksheet

Two sides

Name ______________ Date ____________

Many questions have two sides. A reason FOR gives a good thing about a choice. A reason AGAINST gives a cost or a problem. A fair thinker listens to both sides before they decide.

Warm-up: for or against?

  1. A class talks about a longer recess. Which is a reason FOR it?a) Children get more time to run and playb) Lessons would have less timec) The bell is loud
  2. Same class. Which is a reason AGAINST a longer recess?a) Children like to runb) Lessons would have less timec) Recess is outside
  3. Looking at both sides means you only listen to the side you like.TrueFalse
  4. When a question is about taste, like a favorite pet, two people can both be right.TrueFalse
  5. A school can plant a garden or build a swing set on an empty lot. Which is a reason for the garden?a) Swings are made of metalb) The lot is emptyc) Students can grow vegetables

Weigh the choices

Stretch: costs and benefits

  1. A class can keep a hamster. Which is a reason AGAINST it?a) It likes to run on a wheelb) It needs daily care, even on weekendsc) It has four legs
  2. Which question has two reasonable sides?a) Is a triangle a shape with three sides?b) Should the class have game time on Fridays?c) Is 10 more than 5?
  3. Side A says, 'Homework helps you practice.' Side B says, 'Free time helps you rest.' What is true about both?a) Both give a reasonb) Only A gives a reasonc) Neither gives a reason
  4. A school wants to start earlier so it can end earlier. Which is a benefit?a) Students get more time after schoolb) Some students must wake up earlierc) The bus must come earlier
  5. Same plan. Which is a cost?a) Students get more time after schoolb) Students go home earlierc) Some students must wake up earlier
  6. A fair summary of a disagreement gives each side's best reason.TrueFalse

Fair thinking

Reach: go deeper

  1. Side A: 'A longer lunch lets us eat slowly.' Side B: 'A shorter lunch gives more class time.' What do both sides want?a) To skip lunchb) To use the school day wellc) To end school sooner
  2. Someone says, 'Only one side has good reasons.' What is the best next step?a) Agree right awayb) Stop listeningc) Read the other side's best reasons first
  3. 'Everyone does it' is a weak reason. Why?a) A crowd doing something does not show it is a good ideab) Crowds are always wrongc) Crowds are quiet
  4. A park can add a skate ramp or more benches. Which fact would help most to decide which one more children would use?a) The color of the benchesb) The age of the parkc) A count of children who visit each place
  5. A class votes on a game party or a pizza party. 14 vote for the game party and 9 vote for the pizza party. How many more votes did the game party get?
  6. Hearing both sides means you must always pick the middle.TrueFalse

Both sides table

For a grown-up and child together: pick a small choice, like a pet, a game or a new rule at home. Fill in the table. Then ask: which reason is strongest, and why? What would you need to know to be more sure?

ForAgainst

Made with Peabody Teach, free printables for teachers: teach.peabody.kids. No sign-in, no ads.

Teacher copy with the answer key

Last checked 2026-11-15. Every answer in it was worked out a second time without the key. Something wrong? Tell us.