Skip to the content
Peabody Teach

Share

This page

Peabody is free and has no ads. Sharing it is the best way to help.

Science enrichment: engineering challenges: teacher copy

For the teacher

Gather paper, foil, pennies, tape, two books and a bowl of water. Warm-up covers the design steps, Stretch is the paper bridge and Reach is the foil boat data. Let the child build, test and rebuild, changing one part at a time. Use blunt scissors, and a grown-up should handle any hot glue, knives or heat. Wipe up water spills right away. Allow 30 to 40 minutes.

Think like an engineer

Name ______________ Date ____________

Engineers find a problem, design a fix, build a model, test it and improve it. A model is called a prototype. A goal says what the design must do. A limit is called a constraint.

Warm-up: design steps

  1. An engineer's first try does not work well. What should the engineer do next?a) Say it is perfectb) Change one part and test againc) Stop forever Answer: Change one part and test again
  2. A goal like "must hold 10 pennies" tells you what the design must do.TrueFalse Answer: true
  3. Which material is best for a small boat that must keep water out?a) A paper napkinb) A sheet of aluminum foilc) A sheet of newspaper Answer: A sheet of aluminum foil
  4. What do we call a first test model of a design? Answer: prototype (also: a prototype, model)

The paper bridge

A student builds a bridge from one sheet of paper. It spans a 20 cm gap between two books. A flat sheet holds 6 pennies and then folds.

Stretch: improve the bridge

  1. Which change would most likely make the bridge stronger?a) Cut it into thin stripsb) Fold the paper into pleatsc) Keep it a flat sheet Answer: Fold the paper into pleats
  2. Changing three parts at once makes it easy to know which change helped.TrueFalse Answer: false
  3. The pleated bridge holds 15 pennies. The flat bridge held 6. How many more pennies does it hold? Answer: 9
  4. What do we call a limit, such as "use only one sheet of paper"? Answer: constraint (also: a constraint, constraints)
TryWhat I changedPennies held
1
2
3

The foil boat

A student shapes foil into three boats. Each boat floats in a bowl of water while pennies are added one at a time. The table shows how many pennies each held before sinking.

ShapeTry 1Try 2Try 3
Flat567
Box171918
Wide box242730

Reach: average and explain

  1. What is the average for the flat boat, in pennies? Answer: 6
  2. What is the average for the box boat, in pennies? Answer: 18
  3. What is the average for the wide box boat, in pennies? Answer: 27
  4. The box boat held how many times as many pennies as the flat boat, on average? Answer: 3
  5. Why can a wide box hold more pennies than a flat sheet?a) It pushes aside more water, so the water pushes up moreb) Foil gets heavier in waterc) Pennies get lighter on foil Answer: It pushes aside more water, so the water pushes up more
  6. Testing each shape three times gives more trustworthy results than testing once.TrueFalse Answer: true

Your own challenge

Pick a problem: a stronger bridge, a tower that stands, or a boat that holds more. Write what it must do and its limit. Use blunt scissors. Ask a grown-up for any hot or sharp tools.

Part of my planMy notes
The problem
It must do
The limit
Materials
What I will change after test 1

Draw your design. Label the parts.