Skip to the content
Peabody Teach

Share

This page

Peabody is free and has no ads. Sharing it is the best way to help.

Grade 8 reading practice: Reading stories, set 3: teacher copy

For the teacher

This takes about 20 minutes. Children read the short story and the description of the play, then answer on their own. Use the key to talk about what the play keeps, what it changes, and why a stage might need different choices than a page. Say: "A change is not always a mistake."

The Lamp on the Island

Name ______________ Date ____________

On a small island stood a lighthouse, and in it lived an old keeper who spoke to no one but the gulls. One evening thick fog rolled in. The keeper checked the lamp and found the oil nearly gone. The barrels sat at the bottom of ninety stairs, and the keeper's knees were too sore to carry them.

A girl who delivered supplies by boat had stopped to rest on the dock. She saw the keeper waving from the bottom stair and ran to help. Together they carried the oil, one small can at a time, and lit the lamp. Far out at sea, a fishing boat steered toward the glow and came safely home. "Come back next week," said the keeper. The girl promised she would.

A theater group turned the story into a play. The play keeps the keeper, the fog, the low oil, and the girl who helps. The ninety stairs are shown by a tall stack of crates, and the actors climb only a few of them while a drum beats out the count. Dancers wave gray cloth to make the fog. The play adds a gull that speaks and jokes with the audience. It ends before any boat appears: the lamp glows, and the stage goes dark. The keeper still asks the girl to come back.

Questions

Practice, not an official test. Standard RL.8.7. Circle one answer for each question.

  1. True or false: In both the story and the play, the keeper asks the girl to come back.TrueFalse Answer: true
  2. Which character is added in the play but is not in the story?a) A second keeperb) A fishing captainc) A gull that speaks and jokes Answer: A gull that speaks and jokes
  3. How does the play show the fog?a) Dancers wave gray clothb) The actors say it is foggyc) A drum beats slowly Answer: Dancers wave gray cloth
  4. True or false: In the play, the actors climb all ninety stairs.TrueFalse Answer: false
  5. Which event from the story is left out of the play?a) The girl helps carry the oilb) A fishing boat comes safely homec) The lamp is lit Answer: A fishing boat comes safely home
  6. Why does the play most likely use crates and a drum for the stairs?a) The stage cannot hold ninety real stairs, so the climb is suggestedb) The play wants to change the number of stairsc) The actors did not want to help the keeper Answer: The stage cannot hold ninety real stairs, so the climb is suggested
  7. Which part is the same in the story and the play?a) A girl helps because the lamp oil is lowb) A gull tells jokes to the audiencec) A boat is shown reaching shore Answer: A girl helps because the lamp oil is low
  8. True or false: The play changes the keeper's request that the girl return.TrueFalse Answer: false
  9. Which statement best judges how faithful the play is to the story?a) It is not faithful, because it changes every eventb) It is mostly faithful, because it keeps the main characters and events but changes how some parts are shownc) It is exactly the same, because nothing is added or left out Answer: It is mostly faithful, because it keeps the main characters and events but changes how some parts are shown
  10. Why might the play end with a glowing lamp instead of a boat?a) The keeper no longer wants the lamp litb) A glowing lamp on a dark stage can suggest the rescue without showing a boatc) The girl did not help in the play Answer: A glowing lamp on a dark stage can suggest the rescue without showing a boat