The Pier Lantern
Name ______________ Date ____________
Here is a short story as it is printed. A small lantern hung at the end of the pier. Each night, a girl climbed the steps to light it for the boats at sea. Tonight the wind was strong, and the flame shook inside the glass. She cupped her hands around the lantern and whispered, 'Stay with me.' Slowly, the flame grew steady.
Later, the class watched a stage play of the same story. On stage, a real lantern glowed in the dark, and the sound of waves came from behind the curtain. Instead of whispering, the actor playing the girl spoke out loud so that everyone in the room could hear. A drum beat faster as the wind grew stronger. When the flame steadied, the drum slowed down.
The class talked about the two versions. Readers of the printed story picture the pier and the wind in their own minds. The audience at the play sees and hears these things at once. However, the audience cannot see inside the girl's mind, so they must judge her feelings from her voice and her actions.
Questions
Practice, not an official test. Standard RL.6.7. Circle one answer for each question.
- In the printed story, what did the girl do to protect the flame?a) She blew on it.b) She cupped her hands around the lantern.c) She carried it indoors. Answer: She cupped her hands around the lantern.
- True or false: In the printed story, the girl whispers, 'Stay with me.'TrueFalse Answer: true
- In the play, where did the sound of waves come from?a) From behind the curtainb) From the actorc) From the lantern Answer: From behind the curtain
- How did the play show that the wind was growing stronger?a) A sign told the audience.b) A drum beat faster.c) The actor read from a book. Answer: A drum beat faster.
- True or false: In the play, the drum slowed down when the flame steadied.TrueFalse Answer: true
- Why did the actor speak out loud instead of whispering?a) The girl was angry.b) Everyone in the room needed to hear.c) The drum was too quiet. Answer: Everyone in the room needed to hear.
- Which is something the play gives the audience that the printed story does not?a) Real sounds and lighting that people can hear and seeb) A girl who lights a lanternc) A strong wind Answer: Real sounds and lighting that people can hear and see
- True or false: A reader of the printed story must picture the pier from the words alone.TrueFalse Answer: true
- According to the passage, what can the audience NOT see directly?a) The lanternb) The inside of the girl's mindc) The actor Answer: The inside of the girl's mind
- Which statement is true about BOTH versions?a) The girl whispers to the flame.b) A drum is heard.c) The wind is strong and then the flame steadies. Answer: The wind is strong and then the flame steadies.