Question and materials
Name ______________ Date ____________
Question: Which paper bridge design holds the most weight, and which holds the most for the paper it uses? Engineers test designs, find the failure point and improve. No design is perfect, so you will also look for trade-offs.
Materials: ten sheets of paper, tape, scissors, two stacks of books set 20 cm apart, about 100 pennies, a ruler, a pencil.
Steps
1. Build Design A: one flat sheet across the gap. 2. Build Design B: one sheet folded into an accordion. 3. Build Design C: two sheets rolled into tubes and taped together. 4. Test each one. Add pennies one at a time in the middle until the bridge bends to the table. 5. Record the pennies held. 6. Do three trials for each design. 7. Find the average and the pennies per sheet. 8. Improve your best design. Change one thing and test it three times.
Safety
| Step | What to do | Safety |
|---|---|---|
| 1-3 | Cut and tape the paper | Use scissors only; keep points down |
| 4 | Add pennies one at a time | Keep the load low to the table |
| 4 | Watch the bridge bend | Do not lean over or press down |
| 6 | Repeat each test | Pick up any pennies from the floor |
| End | Clean up the paper | Wash your hands when you finish |
| All | Work together | An adult is nearby |
Data
| Design | Trial 1 | Trial 2 | Trial 3 | Average |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A (flat) | ||||
| B (accordion) | ||||
| C (tubes) | ||||
| D (improved) |
| Design | Sheets | Average | Per sheet |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | 1 | ||
| B | 1 | ||
| C | 2 | ||
| D |
What we found
Use your data and what you learned.
- Design A held 20, 24 and 22 pennies. What is the average?
- Design B held 36, 40 and 44 pennies. What is the average?
- Design A averaged 22 and Design B averaged 40. Which held more?a) Design Ab) They held the samec) Design B
- Design C used 2 sheets and averaged 40 pennies. How many pennies per sheet?
- To make the test fair, you shoulda) change the gap and the paper togetherb) change one thing at a timec) test each design once
- Why do three trials help?a) They make the bridge strongerb) They use more paperc) One trial may be off by chance
- A bridge bends first in the middle. What is a good next step?a) Add folds or tubes at the middle and test againb) Throw the design awayc) Add a longer gap
- Name one trade-off in your best design.