Question and materials
Name ______________ Date ____________
Question: Why does a cut apple turn brown, and how can we tell a chemical change from a physical change? In a chemical change, new substances form. Signs include gas bubbles, a color change and a new smell. In a physical change, such as sugar dissolving or ice melting, no new substance forms.
Materials: apple slices cut ahead of time by an adult, four cups, water, salt, vinegar, baking soda, sugar, a spoon, measuring spoons, a tray, a timer, a marker, paper towels. Do not taste anything.
Steps
Part A, apple slices: 1. Label four cups: air, water, salt water, vinegar water. 2. Put one slice in the air cup with no liquid. Put one slice each in the other cups, covered with 50 mL of each liquid (for salt water, stir in 1 spoon of salt; for vinegar water, use half vinegar and half water). 3. After 5 minutes, lift each slice out and set it on a paper towel. 4. Look at each slice after 10, 30 and 60 minutes.
Part B, the fizz: 5. Put 1 spoon of baking soda in an empty cup on the tray. 6. Slowly pour in 60 mL of vinegar and watch. 7. In another cup, stir 1 spoon of sugar into 60 mL of water. Record what you see for each. Use the same size slices from the same apple so the test is fair.
Safety
| Step | What to do | Safety |
|---|---|---|
| All | Do not taste anything | Foods and liquids are not for eating |
| 2 | Handle the apple slices | An adult cuts the fruit first |
| 6 | Pour vinegar slowly over the tray | Keep vinegar away from eyes |
| 6 | Let the fizz settle | Do not cover the cup tightly |
| End | Wipe spills and wash up | Wash your hands when you finish |
| All | Work together | An adult is nearby |
Data
| Slice in | 10 min | 30 min | 60 min |
|---|---|---|---|
| Air only | |||
| Plain water | |||
| Salt water | |||
| Vinegar water |
Rate the color: 1 = no brown, 2 = a little, 3 = some, 4 = a lot, 5 = dark brown.
| Mixture | Bubbles? | Color change? | Other sign |
|---|---|---|---|
| Baking soda and vinegar | |||
| Sugar and water |
What we found
Use your data and what you learned.
- Which is a sign of a chemical change?a) Bubbles of a new gasb) A paper cut in halfc) Ice melting
- The brown color on a cut apple comes froma) dirt in the airb) a reaction of substances in the apple with oxygenc) the apple melting
- When sugar dissolves in water, the change isa) chemical, because it disappearsb) chemical, because it is clearc) physical, because no new substance forms
- To make the apple test fair, you shoulda) use the same size slices from the same appleb) use different fruitsc) change the time for each cup
- The gas from baking soda and vinegar isa) heliumb) carbon dioxidec) steam only
- A slice was rated 1, 3 and 5 at 10, 30 and 60 minutes. How many points did the rating rise from 10 to 60 minutes?
- Name one sign that a chemical change happened.