Skip to the content
Peabody Teach

Share

This page

Peabody is free and has no ads. Sharing it is the best way to help.

Build a water filter model: teacher copy

For the teacher

Common mix-ups: children think clear water is clean to drink, and that one layer does all the work. Clear water can still hold germs, so nothing in this project is ever drunk. Support: pre-cut the bottles. Stretch: ask children to change one layer and retest. An adult cuts the bottle. About 45 minutes.

Question and design

Name ______________ Date ____________

Question: How clear can we make muddy water with a model filter? Criteria are what the filter must do: make the water clearer. Constraints are the limits: only household materials, one bottle and 10 minutes for each test.

Warning: this is only a model. Filtered water that looks clear may still hold germs. Never drink any of the water in this project.

Make a plan

  1. What is a criterion for this filter?a) Cost nothing at allb) Make the water clearerc) Use a red cup Answer: Make the water clearer
  2. What is a constraint?a) Make the water prettyb) Add soapc) Use only household materials Answer: Use only household materials

Materials and steps

Materials. A plastic bottle. An adult cuts off the bottom. A cup. A coffee filter or cloth. Cotton balls. Sand. Small gravel. Muddy water, made with a little soil and a few leaves. A spoon. A timer. A pencil.

Steps: 1. Turn the bottle upside down in a cup, neck down. 2. Put the cloth in the neck. 3. Add layers: cotton, sand, then gravel. 4. Pour muddy water slowly on top. 5. Time one minute and see what comes through. 6. Rate how clear the water is from 1 (muddy) to 5 (very clear). 7. Take out one layer and test again. 8. Compare designs.

Safety

StepWhat to doSafety
CuttingAn adult cuts the bottleCut edges can be sharp
PouringPour slowlyWipe up spills
Muddy waterNever drink itEven clear water is not safe
Clean upThrow the layers awayWash hands

Record your data

Filter designClarity (1-5)Spoonfuls in 1 min
Cloth only
Cloth and cotton
Cloth, cotton and sand
All layers with gravel

What we found

Use these sample numbers to practice. Design A got a clarity of 2. Design B got 3. Design C got 5. Design C let 4 spoonfuls through in a minute. Design A let 9 spoonfuls through.

Choose the best answer

  1. Which design cleared the water best?a) Design Cb) Design Ac) Design B Answer: Design C
  2. Water that looks clear is always safe to drink.TrueFalse Answer: false
  3. Which design was fastest?a) Design Cb) Design Bc) Design A Answer: Design A
  4. What is the trade-off in Design C?a) Clearer water but slowerb) Dirtier waterc) More coins Answer: Clearer water but slower
  5. How many more spoonfuls did Design A let through than Design C?a) 4b) 5c) 13 Answer: 5
  6. Changing one layer at a time shows what each layer does.TrueFalse Answer: true
  7. What would you do next to improve the filter?a) Change one layer and test againb) Drink the waterc) Stop testing Answer: Change one layer and test again