Question and design
Name ______________ Date ____________
Question: How clear can we make muddy water with a model filter? Criteria are what the filter must do: make the water clearer. Constraints are the limits: only household materials, one bottle and 10 minutes for each test.
Warning: this is only a model. Filtered water that looks clear may still hold germs. Never drink any of the water in this project.
Make a plan
- What is a criterion for this filter?a) Cost nothing at allb) Make the water clearerc) Use a red cup Answer: Make the water clearer
- What is a constraint?a) Make the water prettyb) Add soapc) Use only household materials Answer: Use only household materials
Materials and steps
Materials. A plastic bottle. An adult cuts off the bottom. A cup. A coffee filter or cloth. Cotton balls. Sand. Small gravel. Muddy water, made with a little soil and a few leaves. A spoon. A timer. A pencil.
Steps: 1. Turn the bottle upside down in a cup, neck down. 2. Put the cloth in the neck. 3. Add layers: cotton, sand, then gravel. 4. Pour muddy water slowly on top. 5. Time one minute and see what comes through. 6. Rate how clear the water is from 1 (muddy) to 5 (very clear). 7. Take out one layer and test again. 8. Compare designs.
Safety
| Step | What to do | Safety |
|---|---|---|
| Cutting | An adult cuts the bottle | Cut edges can be sharp |
| Pouring | Pour slowly | Wipe up spills |
| Muddy water | Never drink it | Even clear water is not safe |
| Clean up | Throw the layers away | Wash hands |
Record your data
| Filter design | Clarity (1-5) | Spoonfuls in 1 min |
|---|---|---|
| Cloth only | ||
| Cloth and cotton | ||
| Cloth, cotton and sand | ||
| All layers with gravel |
What we found
Use these sample numbers to practice. Design A got a clarity of 2. Design B got 3. Design C got 5. Design C let 4 spoonfuls through in a minute. Design A let 9 spoonfuls through.
Choose the best answer
- Which design cleared the water best?a) Design Cb) Design Ac) Design B Answer: Design C
- Water that looks clear is always safe to drink.TrueFalse Answer: false
- Which design was fastest?a) Design Cb) Design Bc) Design A Answer: Design A
- What is the trade-off in Design C?a) Clearer water but slowerb) Dirtier waterc) More coins Answer: Clearer water but slower
- How many more spoonfuls did Design A let through than Design C?a) 4b) 5c) 13 Answer: 5
- Changing one layer at a time shows what each layer does.TrueFalse Answer: true
- What would you do next to improve the filter?a) Change one layer and test againb) Drink the waterc) Stop testing Answer: Change one layer and test again