Reading: Which design is better?
Name ______________ Date ____________
People who build things want them to work well. They make a plan. They build a design. Then they test it. Often they build two designs and compare them. A test tells us which one works better. Which house will stand up to a big wind? We can find out.
A test must be fair. We change one thing. We keep the rest the same. We use the same wind for each house. We use the same distance. We count the same number of waves. We test each house more than once. Three tries give us better data than one try. Data are the things we measure or count. We write the data in a table.
Then we look at the data. We say which design is better. We use the data to back up what we say. If a design fails, we do not give up. We change it and test it again. This is how builders make things better.
| Word | What it means |
|---|---|
| design | a plan for how to build a thing |
| compare | look at how two things differ |
| fair test | a test that changes one thing |
| data | facts we measure or count |
| trial | one try of a test |
| improve | make a thing better |
| evidence | facts that show what is true |
Activity: Two paper houses
Materials: paper, tape, scissors (adult), two cups, a paper fan, a ruler, a pencil.
1. Build House A with a wide base. 2. Build House B with a narrow base. 3. Make both the same height. 4. Put the fan one foot away. 5. Wave ten times. 6. Mark if it stood or fell. 7. Do three trials for each house.
| Step | What to do | Safety |
|---|---|---|
| Build | Tape paper to shape | Scissors: adult only |
| Place | Fan one foot away | Keep the fan low |
| Wave | Same ten waves | Do not hit the house |
| Mark | Write stood or fell | Tidy up the paper |
| After | Wash your hands | An adult is nearby |
| House | Trial 1 | Trial 2 | Trial 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| A wide base | |||
| B narrow base |
Practice 1: Recall
Look at the picture word. Pick the best answer.
- Look at the picture word: DATA. What are data?a) Facts we measure or countb) A kind of paperc) A kind of wind Answer: Facts we measure or count
- Look at the picture word: TRIAL. What is a trial?a) One try of a testb) A kind of housec) A table Answer: One try of a test
- What does a design show?a) Who wonb) A plan to buildc) A kind of wind Answer: A plan to build
- What do we do with two designs?a) Compare themb) Hide themc) Tape them together Answer: Compare them
- What is a fair test?a) One that changes one thingb) One that changes many thingsc) One that has no data Answer: One that changes one thing
- Where do we write the data?a) On the wallb) In a tablec) In the wind Answer: In a table
Practice 2: Apply
Pick the best answer.
- House A stood 3 of 3 times. House B stood 1 of 3 times. Which is better?a) House Ab) House Bc) They tie Answer: House A
- You test two houses with different amounts of wind. Is it fair?a) Nob) Yesc) Only if they are red Answer: No
- Your house falls. What should you do?a) Throw it awayb) Change it and test againc) Give up Answer: Change it and test again
- You want to test a house. What should you keep the same?a) The fan distance and wavesb) The color of your shirtc) The day of the week Answer: The fan distance and waves
- One trial shows House A fell once. What is a good next step?a) Do more trialsb) Say A is badc) Say B won Answer: Do more trials
- How many trials did you plan for each house?a) Twob) Threec) One Answer: Three
Practice 3: Explain
Pick the best answer.
- Why do we do three trials?a) To get better datab) To use more paperc) To win Answer: To get better data
- Why must both houses get the same wind?a) So the test is fairb) So the test is quickc) So it is loud Answer: So the test is fair
- What does the data tell you?a) Which paper is blueb) Which design worked betterc) Which house is bigger Answer: Which design worked better
- Why change only one thing at a time?a) So we know what made the differenceb) So we can skip a trialc) So the paper lasts Answer: So we know what made the difference
- How can you back up your claim?a) Show the datab) Say it loudlyc) Say it twice Answer: Show the data
- Why improve a design?a) To make it longerb) To make it work betterc) To make it harder Answer: To make it work better
Check
True or false? Pick one.
- A fair test changes one thing.TrueFalse Answer: true
- One trial is always enough.TrueFalse Answer: false
- We use data to pick the better design.TrueFalse Answer: true
- If a design fails, we should stop.TrueFalse Answer: false
- Both houses get the same number of waves.TrueFalse Answer: true
- We write data in a table.TrueFalse Answer: true
Write about it. Tell which design was better. Use your data to say why.