Skip to the content
Peabody Teach

Share

This page

Peabody is free and has no ads. Sharing it is the best way to help.

Critical thinking: spot the error: teacher copy

For the teacher

For a child who wants more thinking practice. Each item has a small mistake to find. Work through Warm-up first; try Stretch and Reach when ready, and skip any tier that feels like too much. Take about 25 minutes over one or two days. Say that mistakes are a normal part of thinking. Ask the child to say what went wrong, not only the fix. The last page has talking points for you.

Find the mistake

Name ______________ Date ____________

Someone made a mistake in each item. Find it, then fix it. Good thinkers check their work and each other's work.

Warm-up: what went wrong?

  1. A student says, 'A dozen is 10.' What is the error?a) A dozen is 12b) A dozen is 20c) There is no error Answer: A dozen is 12
  2. A student adds 8 + 7 and says 14. What is the right sum? Answer: 15
  3. 'All birds can fly, so a penguin can fly.' What is wrong?a) Penguins are not birdsb) Birds have wingsc) Not all birds can fly Answer: Not all birds can fly
  4. A student says a week has 8 days. The student is right.TrueFalse Answer: false
  5. A student says, 'The sun sets in the east.' What is the error?a) There is no errorb) The sun sets in the westc) The sun does not set Answer: The sun sets in the west
  6. A student says a triangle has 4 sides. How many sides does a triangle really have? Answer: 3

Check the steps

Stretch: fix the reasoning

  1. A student says, 'Half of 18 is 8.' What is half of 18? Answer: 9
  2. A student says, 'Ice is a gas.' Which fix is right?a) Ice is a liquidb) Ice is a solidc) Ice is a plant Answer: Ice is a solid
  3. A student writes 6 x 4 = 20. What is the right product? Answer: 24
  4. 'It rained on Monday and Tuesday, so it will rain all week.' What is the error?a) It never rains two days in a rowb) Monday comes before Tuesdayc) Two days do not prove the rest of the week Answer: Two days do not prove the rest of the week
  5. A team won 4 games. Each win gives 3 points. The coach says the team has 7 points. How many points should it have? Answer: 12
  6. 'Our class has 24 students. 6 are absent, so 30 are here.' This is correct.TrueFalse Answer: false

Trickier mistakes

Reach: find the hidden error

  1. 'I wore a coat and got sick, so coats make you sick.' What kind of mistake is this?a) A spelling mistakeb) Mixing up what happened together with what caused itc) A subtraction mistake Answer: Mixing up what happened together with what caused it
  2. Everyone in the chess club likes puzzles. A student says, 'So everyone at school likes puzzles.' What is the error?a) A club is only part of the schoolb) Chess has piecesc) Puzzles are hard Answer: A club is only part of the school
  3. A pizza has 8 equal slices. A student eats 3 and says 3 are left. How many are left? Answer: 5
  4. From 'All squares are rectangles' and 'This shape is a rectangle,' we must conclude the shape is a square.TrueFalse Answer: false
  5. Ice cream sales and sunburns both go up in summer. A student says ice cream causes sunburns. What is a better explanation?a) Ice cream prevents sunburnsb) Sunburns cause ice cream salesc) Hot sunny weather could cause both Answer: Hot sunny weather could cause both
  6. A student says the mean of 2, 4 and 9 is 4 because 4 is in the middle. Add them up and divide by 3. What is the mean? Answer: 5

Talk it over

For a grown-up: ask your child to make up a short argument with a hidden mistake for you to find. Talk about how it feels to find an error in your own work. Ask: how could we check a claim before we trust it? Which mistakes are about facts, and which are about reasoning?