Skip to the content
Peabody Teach

Share

This page

Peabody is free and has no ads. Sharing it is the best way to help.

Critical thinking: fact or opinion

Three tiers of fact-or-opinion thinking, from warm-up to reach, with a key, for grades 3 to 5.

Grades 3 to 5 · 25 minutes · worksheet

Facts and opinions

Name ______________ Date ____________

A fact can be checked. You can count it, measure it or look it up. An opinion is what a person thinks or feels. People can have different opinions about the same thing.

Warm-up: fact or opinion?

  1. 'A week has seven days.' This is a fact.TrueFalse
  2. 'Pizza is the tastiest lunch.' This is a fact.TrueFalse
  3. 'Ice melts when it gets warm enough.' This is a fact.TrueFalse
  4. 'Summer is the best season.' This is an opinion.TrueFalse
  5. 'A spider has eight legs.' This is an opinion.TrueFalse
  6. 'Rainy days are boring.' This is an opinion.TrueFalse

Pick the fact

Stretch: sort the sentences

  1. Which sentence is a fact?a) Cats are cuter than fish.b) A cat is a mammal.c) Fish make better pets.
  2. Which sentence is an opinion?a) Recess is the best part of school.b) A year has twelve months.c) A triangle has three sides.
  3. Which sentence states a fact about space?a) Snow is more fun than rain.b) Winter is the prettiest season.c) The Moon goes around Earth.
  4. Words like 'best' and 'worst' often show what kind of sentence?a) A factb) An opinionc) A title
  5. 'The soup is hot, so it is delicious.' Which part is the opinion?a) The soup is hotb) It is deliciousc) Neither part
  6. 'Our school has a lunch break.' Is this a fact or an opinion?

Trickier claims

Reach: think harder

  1. Which claim can be checked with a ruler?a) The pencil is the best one.b) The pencil is pretty.c) The pencil is 7 inches long.
  2. Which sentence is a fact claim that is false?a) A spider has six legs.b) Spiders are creepy.c) I like spiders.
  3. 'Most students like the new game rules.' How could you check this?a) Guessb) Ask many studentsc) Ask one student
  4. If an expert says a pizza is delicious, that opinion turns into a fact.TrueFalse
  5. Which sentence mixes a fact and an opinion?a) The game has four players, and it is too hard.b) The game has four players.c) The game is too hard.
  6. In a vote, 12 students said a game is fun and 8 said it is not. How many students voted in all?

Talk it over

For a grown-up: ask your child to explain why, not just to answer. Try these. Can a sentence be a fact and still be wrong? How could you check a fact about the weather? Why do people argue about opinions but not about facts? Ask your child to find one fact and one opinion in a story, a game or a lunch menu. Ask what would change their mind about an opinion.

Made with Peabody Teach, free printables for teachers: teach.peabody.kids. No sign-in, no ads.

Teacher copy with the answer key

Last checked 2026-11-15. Every answer in it was worked out a second time without the key. Something wrong? Tell us.