Skip to the content
Peabody Teach

Share

This page

Peabody is free and has no ads. Sharing it is the best way to help.

Critical thinking: evidence detective: teacher copy

For the teacher

For a child who wants more thinking practice. The child decides what evidence supports a claim and what it does not. Start with Warm-up, then Stretch with a small data table, then Reach. Skip any tier that feels like too much. Allow about 30 minutes over one or two days. The last page has talking points and a space to design a fair test together. Ask: what would change your mind?

What is evidence?

Name ______________ Date ____________

Evidence is information that helps show whether a claim is true. Good evidence can be counted, measured or seen again by other people. A claim with no evidence is only a guess.

Warm-up: pick the evidence

  1. A plant by a window grows taller than a plant in a closet. Which is evidence that light may help plants grow?a) The window plant grew tallerb) The closet has a doorc) Both plants are green Answer: The window plant grew taller
  2. One example proves a rule is true for everything.TrueFalse Answer: false
  3. Which is stronger evidence that a bike helmet fits well?a) One child says sob) A test with 30 childrenc) A guess with no test Answer: A test with 30 children
  4. Evidence is information that can support or weaken a claim.TrueFalse Answer: true
  5. A claim says a garden grew 12 pounds of tomatoes. Which tool gives evidence?a) A thermometerb) A rulerc) A scale Answer: A scale
  6. A student counts 6 birds on Monday, 9 on Tuesday and 6 on Wednesday. How many birds were counted in all? Answer: 21

Read the data

Two plants were grown for a week. One was in light. One was in the dark. Everything else was the same. Here are their heights.

DayPlant in lightPlant in dark
12 cm2 cm
34 cm3 cm
57 cm3 cm
710 cm4 cm

Stretch: what do the numbers say?

  1. How many centimeters did the plant in light grow from Day 1 to Day 7? Answer: 8
  2. How many centimeters did the plant in dark grow from Day 1 to Day 7? Answer: 2
  3. What do the numbers suggest?a) Dark makes plants grow fasterb) Light may help the plant grow morec) Both plants grew the same Answer: Light may help the plant grow more
  4. A team won 8 of 10 games in green socks. A fan says socks cause wins. What else might explain the wins?a) Green is a colorb) The team practiced morec) Socks are made of cotton Answer: The team practiced more
  5. A claim rests on a survey of 5 people. How could the evidence be stronger?a) Ask fewer peopleb) Ask the same person againc) Ask more people Answer: Ask more people
  6. Two plants are enough to prove how all plants grow.TrueFalse Answer: false

Judge the claim

Reach: fair tests and patterns

  1. Ice cream sales and pool visits both rise in summer. Which best explains it?a) Ice cream makes people swimb) Pools sell ice creamc) Warm weather Answer: Warm weather
  2. A test compares two paper airplane folds. What should stay the same in both tests?a) The foldb) The paper size and the way it is thrownc) The distance it flies Answer: The paper size and the way it is thrown
  3. Airplane A flew 12, 15 and 18 feet in three throws. What is the mean distance in feet? Answer: 15
  4. Airplane B flew 10, 10 and 25 feet. What is the median distance in feet? Answer: 10
  5. A single odd result, like a 25 foot throw, should be thrown away without asking why.TrueFalse Answer: false
  6. Drops form on a cold bottle. A student says water leaks through the bottle. Which test checks this best?a) Ask five friendsb) Use colored water and see if the drops are coloredc) Make the water colder Answer: Use colored water and see if the drops are colored
  7. A claim sounds sure but names no source. What is the best response?a) Believe itb) Repeat itc) Ask where the evidence comes from Answer: Ask where the evidence comes from

Design a fair test

For a grown-up and child together: pick a question you can test at home, such as which paper towel soaks up the most water. List what you will change, what you will measure and what you will keep the same. Then ask: what could make our results unfair? How many times should we repeat it?