Skip to the content
Peabody Teach

Share

This page

Peabody is free and has no ads. Sharing it is the best way to help.

Critical thinking: big questions: teacher copy

For the teacher

For a child who wants more thinking practice. The questions on the page are about reasoning: which question can be tested, which needs a definition, what a good reason looks like. Warm-up first, then Stretch and Reach; skip any tier that feels like too much. The last page is for you and the child to talk. Ask big questions at dinner and ask for reasons, not right answers. About 25 minutes.

Kinds of questions

Name ______________ Date ____________

Some questions have one answer you can look up. Some can be tested. Big questions have more than one thoughtful answer. For a big question, a good reason matters more than a quick answer.

Warm-up: which kind of question?

  1. Which question can be answered by a test?a) Does a magnet pick up a paper clip?b) Is blue prettier than green?c) Which song is nicest? Answer: Does a magnet pick up a paper clip?
  2. Which is a big question with more than one thoughtful answer?a) How many legs does a cat have?b) What makes a good game rule?c) What is 4 + 4? Answer: What makes a good game rule?
  3. A big question always has exactly one right answer.TrueFalse Answer: false
  4. A good reason helps explain your answer to a big question.TrueFalse Answer: true
  5. Which question is about ideas and opinions?a) How many seats are on the bus?b) How far is the school from the park?c) What is the most important invention? Answer: What is the most important invention?

Test or think?

Stretch: sort the questions

  1. Which question can be tested?a) Is rain more beautiful than snow?b) Do ice cubes melt faster in warm water than in cold water?c) Should recess be a game? Answer: Do ice cubes melt faster in warm water than in cold water?
  2. Which question can be answered by counting?a) Is lunch the best meal?b) What lunch would be fun?c) How many students bring a lunch from home? Answer: How many students bring a lunch from home?
  3. 'What makes a game fair?' Which is a thoughtful reason?a) Everyone knows the rules before they playb) My team always winsc) Games are games Answer: Everyone knows the rules before they play
  4. Which question needs more information before anyone can answer it?a) Is it a good day for a picnic?b) What is 3 times 3?c) Which is bigger, 9 or 7? Answer: Is it a good day for a picnic?
  5. Two thoughtful people can give different answers to a big question.TrueFalse Answer: true
  6. Which question cannot be settled by one test?a) How fast does a ball roll down a ramp?b) What makes a school day great?c) How long is a pencil? Answer: What makes a school day great?

Bigger thinking

Reach: ask better questions

  1. 'What is the most useful invention?' What should you do first?a) Pick one right awayb) Ask for a testc) Decide what 'useful' means Answer: Decide what 'useful' means
  2. Which paper-towel question can a test answer?a) Which paper towel looks nicest?b) Which paper towel soaks up the most water?c) Which paper towel would a friend pick? Answer: Which paper towel soaks up the most water?
  3. A student says, 'The best sport is the one with the most players.' Which part can be checked by counting?a) How many players each sport hasb) Which sport is bestc) Which sport is fun Answer: How many players each sport has
  4. A big question may change when you learn new facts.TrueFalse Answer: true
  5. A class lists 3 reasons for a longer lunch and 5 reasons against. How many reasons did they list in all? Answer: 8
  6. A thoughtful answer to a big question includes what?a) Only a loud voiceb) A guess with no reasonc) A reason and an example Answer: A reason and an example

Talk it over

For a grown-up: pick one big question and talk for ten minutes. Try these. What makes a rule fair? What is the best way to learn something new? What makes an invention great? What should a good team do when two members disagree? Ask: what reason do you have? What is an example? Is there another way to see it? Write one thought below.