Skip to the content
Peabody Teach

Share

This page

Peabody is free and has no ads. Sharing it is the best way to help.

Science enrichment: what-if questions

What-if questions for grades 4 to 8. Predict what would happen, explain why, and check with numbers. Three tiers with a key.

Grades 4 to 7 · 40 minutes · worksheet

Easy what-ifs

Name ______________ Date ____________

A prediction says what you think will happen. A good scientist also says why. Answer each what-if, then talk about your reason.

Warm-up: predict

  1. What if you drop a thick book and a flat sheet of paper at the same time? What happens?a) The paper lands firstb) The book lands firstc) They land together
  2. What if you leave a metal spoon in hot soup? The handle would get warm.TrueFalse
  3. What if you move a flashlight closer to a wall? The spot of light becomesa) Bigger and dimmerb) The samec) Smaller and brighter
  4. When water freezes, does it expand or shrink?

What if, and why?

For each one, choose a prediction and think of the reason. Write your own what-ifs in the table.

Stretch: predict and explain

  1. What if two balls of the same size and shape, one heavy and one light, are dropped from the same height?a) The heavy one lands much soonerb) They land at nearly the same timec) The light one lands first
  2. What if Earth had no air? A feather and a hammer dropped together would land at the same time.TrueFalse
  3. What if a plant gets 4 hours of light a day for 5 days? How many hours of light in all?
  4. What if a metal spoon and a wooden spoon sit in hot water for one minute? Which handle feels warmer?a) The wooden spoonb) Both feel the samec) The metal spoon
What if...I predictBecause

What if, with numbers

Ice cubes melt into water. No matter is lost when ice melts, so the mass stays the same. A hypothesis is a prediction you can test.

Reach: reason with numbers

  1. What if 6 ice cubes of 10 grams each melt in a cup? What is the mass of the water, in grams?
  2. What if a car moves at 30 miles per hour for 2 hours? How many miles does it travel?
  3. What if a plant grows 3 cm each week? How many centimeters does it grow in 8 weeks?
  4. What if a ball rolls on a rug instead of a wood floor? It stops sooner becausea) Gravity turns offb) The ball gets lighterc) The rug has more friction
  5. When ice melts, the water has less mass than the ice.TrueFalse
  6. What do we call a prediction you can test, such as "warmer water dissolves sugar faster"?

Your own what-ifs

Write three what-ifs of your own. Test one only with a grown-up beside you, using safe home things. No heat, sharp tools or chemicals without a grown-up.

My what-ifMy predictionWhat happened

Draw the what-if you like most. Label what changes.

Made with Peabody Teach, free printables for teachers: teach.peabody.kids. No sign-in, no ads.

Teacher copy with the answer key

Last checked 2026-11-15. Every answer in it was worked out a second time without the key. Something wrong? Tell us.