Skip to the content
Peabody Teach

Share

This page

Peabody is free and has no ads. Sharing it is the best way to help.

Logic puzzles: deduction mysteries: teacher copy

For the teacher

Print the intro page and the three tier pages. Explain that a detective uses only the clues given, never a guess. A child can make a small chart of suspects and clues. Start with the Warm-up and move on when it feels easy. There is no timer. Each mystery has exactly one answer, and nobody is in danger. Ask the child to say which clue ruled out each suspect. Allow about 25 minutes.

How to be a detective

Name ______________ Date ____________

A detective uses only the clues. Each clue rules someone in or out. Make a chart. Mark a suspect with a check if a clue fits and an X if it does not. The answer is the one who is left. Check your answer against every clue.

SuspectClue 1Clue 2Clue 3
the baker
the farmer
the sailor

Mysteries: Warm-up

Warm-up: rule people out

  1. A pie went missing. The thief left flour on the door handle. Three people were near: the baker, the gardener and the sailor. The gardener had dirt on their hands, not flour. The sailor was never in the kitchen. Who took the pie? Answer: baker (also: the baker)
  2. A window was shut at 2:15 and open at 2:30. Only someone in the building during that time could have opened it. The cleaner left at 1:00. The nurse came at 3:00. The teacher stayed from 1:30 to 4:00. Who opened it? Answer: teacher (also: the teacher)
  3. A jar held 24 cookies. Three children each took the same number. Then 6 cookies were left. How many did each child take? Answer: 6
  4. Muddy boot prints of size 9 lead from the garden to the porch. The baker wears size 7. The farmer wears size 9. The clerk wears size 11. Who made the prints?a) the bakerb) the farmerc) the clerk Answer: the farmer
  5. The thief is taller than the baker. The baker is taller than the sailor. True or false: the sailor is taller than the thief.TrueFalse Answer: false

Mysteries: Stretch

Stretch: put the clues together

  1. The baker always tells the truth. The sailor always lies. It is a sunny day with no clouds. One of them says, "It is raining." Who said it? Answer: sailor (also: the sailor)
  2. Four people came to a party, one after another: the baker, the farmer, the sailor and the clerk. The farmer came before the baker. The sailor came last. The clerk came before the farmer. Who came second? Answer: farmer (also: the farmer)
  3. A clock in the hall stopped at 4:20. The vase fell 15 minutes before the clock stopped. At what time did the vase fall? Answer: 4:05 (also: 4:05 pm, 4:05 p.m.)
  4. Three notes were written by a baker, a clerk and a sailor, one note each. The notes are about bread, ships and money. The baker did not write about ships or money. The clerk did not write about ships. Which note did the clerk write?a) moneyb) breadc) ships Answer: money
  5. A bag has 3 times as many red marbles as blue marbles. There are 20 marbles in all. How many are red? Answer: 15
  6. The library book has 12 names. The librarian says 14 people came in, and each person signs the book once or not at all. True or false: if the librarian is right, at least 2 people did not sign.TrueFalse Answer: true

Mysteries: Reach

Reach: long chains of clues

  1. The day after tomorrow is Saturday. What day was yesterday? Answer: Wednesday
  2. All bakers wear aprons. The sailor wears an apron. True or false: the sailor must be a baker.TrueFalse Answer: false
  3. A door code has three different digits, written from smallest to largest. The digits add up to 12. The middle digit is 4. The largest digit is three times the smallest. What is the code? Answer: 246
  4. On a balance, 2 apples weigh the same as 3 plums. One plum weighs the same as 4 grapes. How many grapes weigh the same as 1 apple? Answer: 6
  5. Someone took a key. The baker says, "The farmer took it." The farmer says, "I did not take it." The sailor says, "The baker is not telling the truth." Exactly one of them tells the truth. Who took the key? Answer: farmer (also: the farmer)
  6. Four people sit in seats 1 to 4. The farmer is not in seat 1 or 4. The baker sits left of the farmer. The sailor and the clerk are not next to the baker. The sailor is next to the farmer. Who is in seat 4? Answer: clerk (also: the clerk)