Skip to the content
Peabody Teach

Share

This page

Peabody is free and has no ads. Sharing it is the best way to help.

Talking about stories: Grades 6 to 8: teacher copy

For the teacher

Use this pack before a lesson on claim and evidence, so learners can name each part of an argument out loud. Hand out Starting, Developing and Expanding together; each text tells the same facts, so every learner can join the same talk. Read the picture words aloud, then let learners choose the text that feels right and move up when it gets easy. To make it easier, point to the pictures and read a line at a time. To make it harder, ask for the sentence frames aloud, then in writing. Finish with the check and the talk page.

Picture words

Name ______________ Date ____________

PictureEnglishSpanishMeaning
📣claimafirmacióna main point you want to prove
🔍evidenceevidenciafacts that show a claim is true
💡reasonrazónexplains why evidence fits
🤲supportapoyarhelp show that something is true
📄texttextowords that you read
💬quotecitaexact words from a text
🤔opinionopiniónwhat a person thinks or feels
📊facthechosomething that is true
🗣️explainexplicarmake an idea clear
🏁conclusionconclusiónthe ending of an argument

Starting text

A claim is a main point. Evidence is a fact or quote. Evidence supports the claim. A reason explains the evidence. A conclusion ends the writing.

Sentence frames:

My claim is ___.

A fact is ___.

Developing text

A claim is a main point you want to prove. An opinion is not enough, because readers need proof. Evidence is a fact or a quote from the text. Strong evidence helps support the claim. A reason explains how the evidence supports the claim. I write the claim, and then I give evidence. At the end, a conclusion repeats the claim.

Sentence frames:

My claim is ___.

My evidence is ___.

My reason is ___.

Expanding text

A claim is the main point that a writer wants to prove. An opinion alone is not enough, because readers need proof. Evidence can be a fact, a number or a quote from the text. Strong evidence is true, and it clearly supports the claim. A reason explains how the evidence supports the claim. To write well, I state my claim first and then give two pieces of evidence. After each piece of evidence, I explain my reason in one or two sentences. At the end, a conclusion repeats the claim in new words.

Sentence frames:

This evidence supports my claim because ___.

In conclusion, ___.

Check your reading

Read the text again. Choose the best answer.

  1. What is a claim?a) a main pointb) a page numberc) a title Answer: a main point
  2. What is evidence?a) a guessb) a fact or a quotec) a title Answer: a fact or a quote
  3. What does evidence do?a) ends the writingb) changes the titlec) supports the claim Answer: supports the claim
  4. What does a reason do?a) starts a storyb) explains the evidencec) ends the claim Answer: explains the evidence
  5. What ends the writing?a) a titleb) a reasonc) a conclusion Answer: a conclusion
  6. Which one is evidence?a) a fact from the textb) a feeling with no proofc) a guess Answer: a fact from the text

Talk about it

Talk with a partner. Make a claim about a book or a topic. Give one piece of evidence and explain your reason.

Sentence frames:

My claim is ___.

One piece of evidence is ___.

This supports my claim because ___.