Skip to the content
Peabody Teach

Share

This page

Peabody is free and has no ads. Sharing it is the best way to help.

Secular literature-based homeschool curricula, compared

6 programs, listed alphabetically, each with its grades, method, format and cost a year as the publisher’s own site showed them on October 29, 2026. Open a card for the strengths, the watch-outs and who it fits.

What this list holds

We label a program secular when the publisher's own pages call it secular, or describe the program and the publisher without any faith terms.

Literature-based programs teach through real books, often read aloud, with a schedule that tells you what to read each day and questions or narration to go with it.

At a glance

  • All 6 show a price on the publisher's site. For one child and one year of the main package they run from $39.95 to $1,114.55.
  • How the child works: 6 books and workbooks.
  • All 6 have a placement test or level guide on the publisher's site, linked on each card.
  • Grades: 5 reach pre-K or kindergarten, all reach the elementary grades, 5 reach middle school and 4 reach high school.

Grades each program covers

Beyond the Page
  1. PK
  2. K
  3. 1
  4. 2
  5. 3
  6. 4
  7. 5
  8. 6
  9. 7
  10. 8
  11. 9
  12. 10
  13. 11
  14. 12
BookShark
  1. PK
  2. K
  3. 1
  4. 2
  5. 3
  6. 4
  7. 5
  8. 6
  9. 7
  10. 8
  11. 9
  12. 10
  13. 11
  14. 12
Brave Writer
  1. PK
  2. K
  3. 1
  4. 2
  5. 3
  6. 4
  7. 5
  8. 6
  9. 7
  10. 8
  11. 9
  12. 10
  13. 11
  14. 12
Build Your Library
  1. PK
  2. K
  3. 1
  4. 2
  5. 3
  6. 4
  7. 5
  8. 6
  9. 7
  10. 8
  11. 9
  12. 10
  13. 11
  14. 12
History Quest
  1. PK
  2. K
  3. 1
  4. 2
  5. 3
  6. 4
  7. 5
  8. 6
  9. 7
  10. 8
  11. 9
  12. 10
  13. 11
  14. 12
Torchlight
  1. PK
  2. K
  3. 1
  4. 2
  5. 3
  6. 4
  7. 5
  8. 6
  9. 7
  10. 8
  11. 9
  12. 10
  13. 11
  14. 12
Alphabetical, as the table below. Each row lights the grades the publisher states.
Which grades are you shopping for?

5 of the 6 reach pre-K or kindergarten:

  • Beyond the Page Age levels 4-5 to 12-14 (about pre-K to 8th grade), plus High School 1 for 9th or 10th grade
  • BookShark Levels Pre-K to J plus high school levels, ages 4 to 18 (about pre-K to 12th grade)
  • Brave Writer Ages 5 to 18, about kindergarten to 12th grade, in five age bands
  • Build Your Library Level 0 (kindergarten) to Level 12 (12th grade)
  • Torchlight Levels Pre-K to 5, roughly the matching grades

All 6 reach the elementary grades:

  • Beyond the Page Age levels 4-5 to 12-14 (about pre-K to 8th grade), plus High School 1 for 9th or 10th grade
  • BookShark Levels Pre-K to J plus high school levels, ages 4 to 18 (about pre-K to 12th grade)
  • Brave Writer Ages 5 to 18, about kindergarten to 12th grade, in five age bands
  • Build Your Library Level 0 (kindergarten) to Level 12 (12th grade)
  • History Quest 1st to 6th grade; United States is for 3rd to 6th, and the Modern History Bridge book reaches 7th grade
  • Torchlight Levels Pre-K to 5, roughly the matching grades

5 of the 6 reach middle school:

  • Beyond the Page Age levels 4-5 to 12-14 (about pre-K to 8th grade), plus High School 1 for 9th or 10th grade
  • BookShark Levels Pre-K to J plus high school levels, ages 4 to 18 (about pre-K to 12th grade)
  • Brave Writer Ages 5 to 18, about kindergarten to 12th grade, in five age bands
  • Build Your Library Level 0 (kindergarten) to Level 12 (12th grade)
  • History Quest 1st to 6th grade; United States is for 3rd to 6th, and the Modern History Bridge book reaches 7th grade

4 of the 6 reach high school:

  • Beyond the Page Age levels 4-5 to 12-14 (about pre-K to 8th grade), plus High School 1 for 9th or 10th grade
  • BookShark Levels Pre-K to J plus high school levels, ages 4 to 18 (about pre-K to 12th grade)
  • Brave Writer Ages 5 to 18, about kindergarten to 12th grade, in five age bands
  • Build Your Library Level 0 (kindergarten) to Level 12 (12th grade)
Alphabetical. We never rank programs, and none pays to appear.
ProgramSubjectsGradesMethodFormatCost a yearFaith label
Beyond the PageEpiphany Curriculum, LLCAll subjectsPre-K–10Literature-basedBooks and workbooks$1,114.55Secular
BookSharkBookSharkAll subjectsPre-K–12Literature-basedBooks and workbooks$1,040.94Secular
Brave WriterBrave WriterLanguage artsK–12Literature-basedBooks and workbooks$247Secular
Build Your LibraryBuild Your LibraryAll subjectsK–12Literature-based, Charlotte MasonBooks and workbooks$39.95Secular
History QuestPandia PressHistory and geography1–7Literature-basedBooks and workbooks$101.98Secular
TorchlightTorchlight CurriculumAll subjectsPre-K–5Literature-basedBooks and workbooks$47Secular

Each program in a line

  • Beyond the Page: A family with a curious, confident reader who wants science, social studies and language arts tied together through real books and projects, with a parent ready to lead each day.
  • BookShark: A family that wants a fully planned, book-based year with a free fifth day, and likes siblings sharing history and science.
  • Brave Writer: A parent who wants to coach writing through good books and conversation, with one relaxed program for one or several children.
  • Build Your Library: A family that wants a book-centered year planned for them at low cost, with time to read aloud together.
  • History Quest: A family with several elementary children who wants history told as a story, with a weekly mix of crafts, mapping and writing.
  • Torchlight: A family that wants literature, history and science planned around read-aloud books and discussion, at a low price.

7 things to look for in secular literature-based homeschool curricula

  1. That label is the only thing these pages say about religion. If it matters to you, read the publisher's own pages.
  2. Count the books a year needs and how many you can borrow. Check how much of the day is the parent reading aloud, and whether that suits your family.
  3. Give the placement test before you pay. Every program here links one on the publisher's site: Beyond the Page, BookShark, Brave Writer, Build Your Library, History Quest and Torchlight. Levels rarely line up with school grades, and it is cheaper to find that out first.
  4. Look at what the price covers. For one child and one year of the main package, Build Your Library is $39.95 and Beyond the Page is $1,114.55. The gap is usually books, a teacher's guide, tests or a subscription, so read what each price includes.
  5. Check where the series ends. History Quest and Torchlight stop before high school, so you would switch programs later; the others carry on to 9th grade or beyond.
  6. Ask how much the parent teaches. History Quest: The publisher says the chapter book is a read-aloud for 1st to 4th grade and an independent read from 5th grade.
  7. Open the sample lessons the publisher posts and read one the way your child would meet it. Ten minutes with a real lesson tells you more than a description.

By grade: which programs reach your child

Pre-K and kindergarten

Beyond the Page (Age levels 4-5 to 12-14 (about pre-K to 8th grade), plus High School 1 for 9th or 10th grade), BookShark (Levels Pre-K to J plus high school levels, ages 4 to 18 (about pre-K to 12th grade)), Brave Writer (Ages 5 to 18, about kindergarten to 12th grade, in five age bands), Build Your Library (Level 0 (kindergarten) to Level 12 (12th grade)), Torchlight (Levels Pre-K to 5, roughly the matching grades)

Elementary (1st to 5th grade)

Beyond the Page (Age levels 4-5 to 12-14 (about pre-K to 8th grade), plus High School 1 for 9th or 10th grade), BookShark (Levels Pre-K to J plus high school levels, ages 4 to 18 (about pre-K to 12th grade)), Brave Writer (Ages 5 to 18, about kindergarten to 12th grade, in five age bands), Build Your Library (Level 0 (kindergarten) to Level 12 (12th grade)), History Quest (1st to 6th grade; United States is for 3rd to 6th, and the Modern History Bridge book reaches 7th grade), Torchlight (Levels Pre-K to 5, roughly the matching grades)

Middle school (6th to 8th grade)

Beyond the Page (Age levels 4-5 to 12-14 (about pre-K to 8th grade), plus High School 1 for 9th or 10th grade), BookShark (Levels Pre-K to J plus high school levels, ages 4 to 18 (about pre-K to 12th grade)), Brave Writer (Ages 5 to 18, about kindergarten to 12th grade, in five age bands), Build Your Library (Level 0 (kindergarten) to Level 12 (12th grade)), History Quest (1st to 6th grade; United States is for 3rd to 6th, and the Modern History Bridge book reaches 7th grade)

High school (9th to 12th grade)

Beyond the Page (Age levels 4-5 to 12-14 (about pre-K to 8th grade), plus High School 1 for 9th or 10th grade), BookShark (Levels Pre-K to J plus high school levels, ages 4 to 18 (about pre-K to 12th grade)), Brave Writer (Ages 5 to 18, about kindergarten to 12th grade, in five age bands), Build Your Library (Level 0 (kindergarten) to Level 12 (12th grade))

Lowest to highest cost a year

An order by price, not by quality. One child, one year of the main package, as the publisher’s site showed it; every program on this list shows a price.

  1. Build Your Library: $39.95
  2. Torchlight: $47
  3. History Quest: $101.98
  4. Brave Writer: $247
  5. BookShark: $1,040.94
  6. Beyond the Page: $1,114.55

What each does well, and what to watch for

  • Beyond the Page. Does well: A full-year package includes the required novels, science kits and manipulatives, so most of the year arrives in one order. Watch for: The four-subject Age 8-10 package is $1,114.55, so a full year is a large purchase for one child.
  • BookShark. Does well: Instructor's guides plan 36 weeks on a 4-day schedule, leaving a fifth day free, with answer keys, discussion questions and background notes. Watch for: A Level C all-subject package costs over $900 even at 20% off.
  • Brave Writer. Does well: The PDFs are not consumable and can be used with more than one child, especially children close in age. Watch for: All sales of the digital products are final, with no refunds.
  • Build Your Library. Does well: A full year of lesson plans costs $39.95, so most of the spending goes to books, which you can also borrow from a library. Watch for: Math is not included, and you may need separate spelling and grammar programs.
  • History Quest. Does well: Every week follows the same five-day pattern (read, imaginary trip, create, write, enrich), so the plan is laid out for you. Watch for: You also need The Usborne Encyclopedia of World History and several literature books, which Pandia Press does not sell with the course.
  • Torchlight. Does well: A full year's plan costs $47 as a PDF, and you may print it for your own family. Watch for: Math and reading instruction are not included after Pre-K, so you add your own programs.

Who each one is not for

  • Beyond the Page: A family on a tight budget, or one that wants a child to work alone through a workbook or a screen with little parent time.
  • BookShark: A family on a tight budget, or one that wants workbook drills or video teaching instead of reading and discussion.
  • Brave Writer: A family that wants a scripted workbook a child can do alone, or wants the option of a refund.
  • Build Your Library: A family that wants math included, printed teacher guides, or a box that arrives with every book.
  • History Quest: A family that wants a short, low-prep history workbook, or one program that runs through middle and high school.
  • Torchlight: A family that wants math and reading included, printed books, or schoolbooks a child reads alone.

Before you buy

That label is the only thing these pages say about religion. If it matters to you, read the publisher's own pages.

Count the books a year needs and how many you can borrow. Check how much of the day is the parent reading aloud, and whether that suits your family.

Most publishers post samples and a placement test; each card links the placement test where the publisher has one.

Side by side

Related lists

Questions parents ask

What are the options for secular literature-based homeschool curricula?

6 programs are on this list: Beyond the Page, BookShark, Brave Writer, Build Your Library, History Quest and Torchlight. Each has a card with its grades, method, format, cost a year, strengths, watch-outs and who it fits, with the publisher's page linked for every fact.

Which is the best of the secular literature-based homeschool curricula?

We do not rank programs, because the best one is the one your child will do and you can keep up with. Narrow the list by your child's grade, by what you can spend and by how much you want to teach yourself, then give the placement test or open a sample lesson from two or three. The card for each program says who it fits and who it does not.

How much do secular literature-based homeschool curricula cost?

For one child and one year of the main package, prices on the publishers' sites run from $39.95 (Build Your Library) to $1,114.55 (Beyond the Page). Prices change; the date each was read is on its card.

Do secular literature-based homeschool curricula have a placement test?

All link a placement test or level guide on the publisher's own site: Beyond the Page, BookShark, Brave Writer, Build Your Library, History Quest and Torchlight.

Which grades do secular literature-based homeschool curricula cover?

By grade band: Pre-K and kindergarten, 5 of 6; Elementary (1st to 5th grade), all of 6; Middle school (6th to 8th grade), 5 of 6; High school (9th to 12th grade), 4 of 6. Each card gives the exact range as the publisher states it.

How we label

Every fact on a card was read on the publisher's own website on the date shown, and the page it came from is linked. A fact we could not confirm there is left out. Costs are for one child and one year of the main package, as the publisher's page showed them that day; prices and sales change. Method and format are the publisher's own description where it gives one. The only thing we say about religion is one label, secular or faith-based, given by the rule above; where the publisher's pages don't settle it, the card has no label.

No affiliate links, no sponsored places, no ranking. Something wrong or out of date? Send a correction; publishers can send corrections, never money.