Skip to the content
Peabody Teach

Share

This page

Peabody is free and has no ads. Sharing it is the best way to help.

Sonlight vs BookShark

Checked October 29, 2026No affiliate links. Programs never pay to appear.

The main differences

Both teach through real books, with 36-week instructor's guides that schedule read-alouds, readers, language arts and science, and both put Math-U-See and Handwriting Without Tears in their all-subject packages. Sonlight goes by grade and offers a 4-day or 5-day schedule. BookShark goes by levels set by age, on a 4-day week, and lets children within three years of age share history and science. Sonlight lets you use a complete package for up to 18 weeks and return it for a full refund; BookShark takes returns within 30 days.

Rows where the two differ are shaded. Every fact is from the publisher’s own site.
SonlightBookShark
SubjectsAll subjects: math, reading and phonics, language arts, science and history and geographyAll subjects: math, reading and phonics, language arts, science and history and geography
GradesPreschool to 12th gradeLevels Pre-K to J plus high school levels, ages 4 to 18 (about pre-K to 12th grade)
MethodLiterature-basedLiterature-based
FormatBooks and workbooksBooks and workbooks
Faith labelFaith-basedSecular
Cost a year$1,129.45. 3rd grade All-Subjects Package C, 4 days a week, with required resources (instructor's guides, history and literature books, readers, language arts, handwriting, science and Math-U-See Gamma): $1,129.45 today, 20% off $1,411.81. Families new to Sonlight are pointed to a History B+C version of this package instead.$1,040.94. Level C All-Subject Package (ages 7 to 9, grades 2 to 4) with required resources (instructor's guides, history, science and reading books, language arts, handwriting, Math-U-See Beta, timeline book, map and binder): $1,040.94, 20% off $1,301.18. Without the required resources it is $925.77.
PlacementFree placement tests ↗Free placement tests ↗
Parent timeNot stated by the publisherNot stated by the publisher
It fitsA family that wants to learn through real books read together, with every day of the year planned in a guide.A family that wants a fully planned, book-based year with a free fifth day, and likes siblings sharing history and science.
It doesn't fitA family on a tight budget, or one that wants the child to work alone from workbooks or a screen.A family on a tight budget, or one that wants workbook drills or video teaching instead of reading and discussion.

Sonlight

Sonlight is a literature-based curriculum: history, geography and literature are taught through read-aloud books and readers, scheduled together with language arts and science in a 36-week instructor's guide. An all-subjects package for a grade includes the guides, the books, language arts, handwriting, science and a math program, on a 4-day or 5-day schedule. It runs from preschool to 12th grade, and the parent teaches from the guides and shares the read-alouds.

Does well: An all-subjects package arrives with the whole year planned: 36 weeks of lesson plans and notes that tie the subjects together.

Watch for: A 3rd grade package costs over $1,100 even at 20% off.

The full Sonlight card · Publisher’s site ↗

BookShark

BookShark is a literature-based curriculum organized by levels rather than grades: history, science and language arts are taught through read-alouds, readers and other real books, on a 36-week, 4-day schedule set out in instructor's guides. An all-subject package for one child includes the guides, the books, language arts, handwriting, science and a math program, plus optional online access for reading schedules and auto-graded assessments. Levels run from pre-K (ages 4 to 5) to high school.

Does well: Instructor's guides plan 36 weeks on a 4-day schedule, leaving a fifth day free, with answer keys, discussion questions and background notes.

Watch for: A Level C all-subject package costs over $900 even at 20% off.

The full BookShark card · Publisher’s site ↗

Lists with both

How we label

Every fact on a card was read on the publisher's own website on the date shown, and the page it came from is linked. A fact we could not confirm there is left out. Costs are for one child and one year of the main package, as the publisher's page showed them that day; prices and sales change. Method and format are the publisher's own description where it gives one. The only thing we say about religion is one label, secular or faith-based, given by the rule above; where the publisher's pages don't settle it, the card has no label.

Something wrong or out of date? Send a correction; publishers can send corrections, never money. Every program compared