Heart of Dakota vs My Father's World
The main differences
Both plan a year of living books, narration and hands-on work from one teacher's guide, from preschool through high school. Heart of Dakota lays out each day on a two-page spread, says a 2nd or 3rd grader's day takes about 3 to 3 and a half hours, and sells a year as a core package plus science, math and grammar packages, which came to $677.06 on sale. My Father's World puts children from 4th to 8th grade into one shared family cycle; its 3rd grade package was $385.74 before math and language arts.
| Heart of Dakota | My Father's World | |
|---|---|---|
| Subjects | All subjects: math, language arts, science and history and geography | All subjects: math, reading and phonics, language arts, science and history and geography |
| Grades | Preschool to 12th grade | Preschool (from age 2) to 12th grade |
| Method | Charlotte Mason, Unit studies | Charlotte Mason, Classical, Unit studies, Literature-based |
| Format | Books and workbooks | Books and workbooks |
| Faith label | Faith-based | Faith-based |
| Cost a year | $677.06. Guide for grades 2 and 3, at sale prices: Economy Package (teacher's guide plus books for subjects including history, geography, spelling, poetry and art) $255.80, Science Package $342.28, and the lowest-priced Basic Package with grammar and Singapore Math $78.98, together $677.06 (list prices $294.02, $402.68 and $89.74). Reading sets, read-alouds, handwriting and consumables are extra. | $385.74. 3rd grade World Changers package (teacher's manual with daily lesson plans, plus the history, science, art and music books): $385.74 today, 20% off $482.17. Math and language arts are required and bought separately. |
| Placement | Guide placement charts ↗ | None on the publisher's site |
| Parent time | Not stated by the publisher | Not stated by the publisher |
| It fits | A parent who wants open-and-go daily plans built on living books, with a known length of school day and a choice of math program. | A family teaching several children that wants one plan for history, science and the arts, with books, notebooking and hands-on projects. |
| It doesn't fit | A family that wants one box with every subject at one price, or lessons taught mostly on a screen. | A family that wants every subject in one box, or a child who works alone on a screen. |
Heart of Dakota
Heart of Dakota is a Charlotte Mason-inspired curriculum taught in a unit-study way, built around one teacher's guide a year from preschool through high school. Each guide gives open-and-go daily plans on a two-page spread, with living books for history and science, narration, copywork, dictation and poetry. The guide for grades 2 and 3 runs 34 weeks, five days a week, about 3 to 3½ hours a day for the child, and you buy it in a core package and add packages for science, math and grammar, reading and more.
Does well: Each day is laid out on a two-page spread with every subject in its own box, so the parent can open the guide and teach.
Watch for: The core package does not include science, math or grammar, so a full year means buying several packages.
My Father's World
My Father's World is a curriculum for preschool to 12th grade that teaches history, science, art, music and much of language arts from one teacher's manual with daily lesson plans, read-aloud books, notebooking and hands-on projects. From 4th to 8th grade, children of several ages study the same package together in a five-year cycle. Math, and from 2nd grade the grade-level language arts books, are bought separately; the publisher recommends Dimensions Math.
Does well: One primary teacher's manual guides all subjects, with daily lesson plans in a weekly chart, so the parent does not have to plan.
Watch for: Math is not in the packages and is bought separately, and families new to the recommended Dimensions Math must take its placement test first.
Lists with both
- Homeschool all-in-one curricula 32
- Faith-based homeschool curricula 29
- Charlotte Mason homeschool curricula 10
- Unit study homeschool curricula 9
- Homeschool curricula for pre-K and kindergarten 75
- Homeschool curricula for middle school 87
- Homeschool curricula for high school 58
- Print homeschool curricula 71
How we label
Every fact on a card was read on the publisher's own website on the date shown, and the page it came from is linked. A fact we could not confirm there is left out. Costs are for one child and one year of the main package, as the publisher's page showed them that day; prices and sales change. Method and format are the publisher's own description where it gives one. The only thing we say about religion is one label, secular or faith-based, given by the rule above; where the publisher's pages don't settle it, the card has no label.
Something wrong or out of date? Send a correction; publishers can send corrections, never money. Every program compared